Some basic info about specific women whose learning is acknowledged in the Talmud (vs., e.g. texts about women or women’s learning or, more generally, the status of women).

For a general timeline including some Talmudic figures (although no women), visit Jewish Intellectual Timeline. (A number of the links in that timeline are to Wikipedia pages, as are some below — I’ll add more variety when I have time.) My Jewish Learning offers lots of good background on Talmud and its culture. (Materials on Talmud in general and women in Talmud, from the November 2008 Kol Isha session at Temple Micah are Women and Talmud)–

Below are some print resources and a few more links, but here are some basics regarding some of the most prominent women of learning in the Talmud:

Period of the Tannaim, Palestine, around 70-200 CE
[Aramaic, like the Hebrew “shana,” to repeat, as in “Mishnah”]

Imma (or Ima) Shalom

  • Learned woman of the late 1st/early 2nd Century CE in the family of Hillel.
    Wife of Eliezer ben Hyrcanus.
  • Sister of Gamaliel II (sometimes called his daughter, with a reconciling note that she was raised in his care); she and Gamaliel are grandchildren of Gamaliel the Elder, grandson to Hillel.
  • Imma Shalom, unlike Beruriah (below), is never cited as a legal authority in her own right. She does appear, however, in a number of stories involving halachic (legal) rulings. In one — the aftermath of the “snake oven” (Akhnai) story — she cites a teaching from her grandfather’s house concerning prayer and the “gate of wounded feelings.” She is considered by some scholars to be a “literary construct” and was adopted by feminists of the late 20th Century CE as proof that women could — and did — learn and play important roles in ancient Jewish culture.
    —–An older on-line source and a recent midrash:

  • Jewish Encyclopedia
  • The oven that coiled like a snake


    Beruriah

  • 2nd Century CE scholar, only woman in the Talmud cited as legal authority.
  • Wife of Meir.
  • Daughter of (martyr) Hanania ben Teradion.
  • Like Imma Shalom, Beruriah is sometimes believed to be a “literary construct,” rather than a historical or semi-historical character. Several Talmudic passages in which she appears to best a male colleague made her a heroine of mid-20th Century CE feminism; this served to diminish, in some ways, her teachings themselves, according to Dalia Hoshen, author of Beruria the Tannait University Press of America). Hoshen argues that rather than being either heretical (like Aher, see below) or subversive as a woman (as int he “construct” view), Beruriah is solidly of the Tanna mold.
    —–On-line references spanning a century —

  • Jewish Encyclopedia
    (1901-1906, note that Henrietta Szold is a co-author of this article)
  • MyJewishLearning (2003 article)


  • Daughter of Acher

  • Otherwise unnamed, woman of the 2nd Century CE.
  • Daughter of heretic Elisha ben Abuya, known as “Acher” [“the Other”].
  • Appears before Rabbi, Yehuda HaNasi (Judah the Prince), to demand financial support.
  • When Rabbi learns the identity of Acher’s daughter he refuses her request, but she presents an argument based on the merit of Torah learning: “Remember his Torah and do not remember his deeds.” Fire then comes down, nearly burning Rabbi (a student, by the way, of Meir and Meir’s teacher, Elisha ben Abuya), and Rabbi realizes his mistake.


    Period of the Amora, roughly 200 – 500 CE
    [Aramaic, “those who say”]
    Yalta

  • Prominent woman of 3rd-4th Century CE Babylon.
  • Daughter of “the Exilarch” (or “reish galuta,” in Aramaic, Jewish leader in Babylon), which some assume is Rabba ben Abuha and others identify as another Exilarch.
  • Often recognized as the wife of Nachman (bar Yaakov), sometimes as his patron.

  • Rachel Adler discusses a story about Yalta, Nachman and a traveling rabbi named ‘Ulla in her book Engendering Judaism: An Inclusive Theology and Ethics, parts of which can be read on-line through GoogleBooks. (Type in “Engendering Judaism,” and search for Yalta.)



    More Resources
    Women in the Talmud: An anthology of the Talmud’s stories about women, from Seder Zeraim and Moed, as explained by the classic commentators. Rabbi Dr. Aaron Glatt
    ISBN: 1-57819-710-4 — http://www.artscroll.com/index.html

  • Here is an excerpt concerning unnamed wife of Chanina ben dosa.
  • Extensive, careful review by Avraham Bronstein is available at The Commentator, but readers must register (free) first. Look for “Talmudic Women, Glatt or not?”
  • Ultimately, the book does not really present a specific thesis with regards to the rabbinic attitude towards women. Still, it is a thorough listing of the Talmudic stories that involve women complemented by a clear, accessible presentation of some of the traditional commentaries. It might even happen that someone will sit down some Shabbat afternoon, read one of the stories, continue into the commentary, and, focused on reading a book about “Women in the Talmud,” think critically about their own reactions to the story and how the traditional commentators read it. If that happens, the book will have done more good for the traditional community than it ever could have as a response to the progressive community.


    The Commentator review notes that Women in the Talmud is meant as something of a response to feminist literature about women in the Talmud, presumably some or all of the following, plus Engendering Judaism mentioned above. It does appear that some form of dialogue has begun although it is not clear exactly who is hearing whom.

  • Midrashic Women: Formations of the Feminine in Rabbinic Literature. Judith R. Baskin, 2002.
  • Judith Romney Wegner. Chattel or Person? The Status of Women in the Mishnah. Oxford University Press, New York, 1988.
  • See also,

  • The Jewish Woman in Rabbinic Literature: A Psychohistorical Perspective. Menachem M. Brayer, Ktav, 1985.
  • Talmudic Stories: Narrative Art, Composition and Culture. Jeffery L. Rubenstein, 2003. Available in part through Google Books.
  • The Rebbetzin’s Husband’s blog on “Women in the Talmud, lists women who exemplify certain roles, such as “stickler for mitzvot” and “scholar”
  • Posted by vspatz

    Virginia blogs on Jewish topics at "A Song Every Day" and manages the Education Town Hall and #WeLuvBooks sites. More at Vspatz.wordpress.com

    Leave a Reply

    Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

    WordPress.com Logo

    You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

    Twitter picture

    You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

    Facebook photo

    You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

    Google+ photo

    You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

    Connecting to %s